Blog · Extra services

Charging guests upfront for extra services

Charging in advance stops last-minute cancellations, but the law limits what you can keep. What Spanish consumer law, the Civil Code and the Balearic tourism decree say, and how to write a policy that holds up.

The short rule

Charging a private chef, a massage or a boat trip before it happens is legal and, done well, it is what stops last-minute "we're not coming after all". What the law watches is how you charge: how much you take upfront, what you keep if the guest cancels and what you give back if you cancel. Three texts decide it: Spain's general consumer law (Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007), the Civil Code and, in the Balearics, the tourism decree (Decree 20/2015).

Does the guest get 14 days to change their mind?

If they book at a distance (website, email, WhatsApp, an app), generally yes: article 102 gives 14 calendar days to withdraw without giving a reason, and article 102.2 makes any clause penalising that void. But article 103.l excludes contracts for accommodation, transport of goods, vehicle rental, catering or services related to leisure activities when the contract sets a specific date or period of performance.

In practice:

ServiceCovered by 103.l?
Private chef on SaturdayYes, catering on a date
Half-day boat trip on TuesdayYes, leisure on a date
Car or bike rentalYes, vehicle rental on dates
Massage, airport transfer, late check-outNot named: a matter of interpretation

For the ones that don't fit, the safe route is to fix a day and time in the booking and, if the service happens within the 14 days, have the guest expressly ask for it to start: article 103.a removes the withdrawal right once the service has been fully performed with their prior consent. And withdrawal only exists for distance or off-premises contracts (article 92): what a guest orders face to face at reception doesn't carry it.

Deposits and cancellation fees: what you can keep

No withdrawal right doesn't mean you can keep everything. The same law sets the limits:

  • Proportionate fees. It is unfair to impose "disproportionately high compensation" on a consumer who doesn't perform (article 85.6). Keeping 100 % of a chef cancelled three weeks ahead is hard to defend; 100 % the evening before, when the chef has already shopped, is easier.
  • Symmetry. It is unfair to keep what the consumer paid when they withdraw without providing an equivalent amount if you withdraw (article 87.2). If you keep the deposit when the guest cancels, your policy must say that if you (or your provider) cancel, the guest gets the money back plus the same compensation.
  • No charging for what isn't provided. It is unfair to keep payment for services not provided when you end the contract (87.4), or to charge for services not actually used (87.5).
  • Guarantees that match the risk. It is unfair to demand "guarantees disproportionate to the risk assumed" (article 88.1). A €2,000 security deposit for a kayak tour won't pass.

The Civil Code adds two useful pieces. If you call the payment an "arras" deposit, article 1454 lets the client walk away by losing it and you walk away by returning it doubled (it is written for sales and applied to services by analogy, so say in your policy what each payment is). And if you agree a penalty clause, a judge can reduce it when the service was partly performed (article 1154).

What the Balearic tourism decree says

Decree 20/2015 (article 87, consolidated text) requires prices to be given before the client accepts, with proof of receipt kept for two years; invoices to show advance payments and guarantees already made; and says that cancelling a booking, except for force majeure, gives rise to compensation on the terms agreed when it was made. In other words, your cancellation policy is worth exactly what the guest accepted in writing.

The Balearic Tourism Act 8/2012 adds that published prices must be final and complete, with taxes and extra charges (article 19.e), that you must have official complaint forms (19.j; also article 49 of the Balearic consumer law 7/2014) and that breaching the bookings and cancellations rules is a minor offence (article 118.n).

Cards: hold instead of charge

With a card you can charge now or hold the amount and capture it later. Spain's payment services law (Royal Decree-law 19/2018, article 47) only allows funds to be blocked if the cardholder has consented to the exact amount, and requires them to be released without delay once the final amount is known. Article 48 lets them claim back a merchant-initiated charge if the authorisation didn't specify the amount and the charge exceeds what they could reasonably expect. Remote payments need strong customer authentication (article 68), with exemptions such as amounts up to €30 (Delegated Regulation 2018/389, article 16).

On Stripe, for example, a hold on an online card payment lasts 7 days for Visa, Mastercard, Amex and Discover; extended authorisation of up to 30 days exists, with conditions by card brand and business type. If it expires uncaptured, the money is released automatically. One difference that matters: cancelling a hold costs nothing, but when you refund a payment Stripe keeps its fee. For a service three days away, holding usually beats charging and refunding.

A policy that works in practice

  1. A fixed price in writing before acceptance: what it includes, taxes and any surcharge (travel, public holidays).
  2. Deadlines per service, not one for everything: a massage is easy to move; a chef who buys produce or a boat that turns down other trips isn't.
  3. Simple tiers: free until X days or hours before, 50 % until Y, 100 % after. Keep what you retain close to what you actually lose.
  4. Written symmetry: if you or the provider cancel, a full refund and the same compensation you would ask of the guest.
  5. Weather and force majeure: for boats and outdoor activities, say who calls a weather cancellation and that the guest then gets a full refund or another day.
  6. Quick refunds by the same method: article 107 requires refunds within 14 calendar days after a withdrawal; using that as your general rule prevents complaints.
  7. Invoices showing advance payments: the Balearic decree requires it and it saves arguments at check-out.

If the extra is sold before arrival together with the stay and makes up 25 % or more of the total, it can be a package holiday, with its own cancellation rules (article 160: an "appropriate and justifiable" termination fee, a full refund in unavoidable and extraordinary circumstances and repayment within 14 days). We cover it in Private chef, massage and boat trips with no staff.

At GetMallorca

In GetMallorca's guest apps each service carries its fixed price, minimum notice and cancellation note, which the guest sees before requesting it; payment, when switched on, runs through the property's own Stripe account.

Frequently asked questions

Can a guest withdraw within 14 days from a chef or boat trip booked online?

Not if the service has a set date: article 103.l of Spain's consumer law excludes catering, vehicle rental and leisure services with a specific date or period. Massages, transfers or late check-out aren't named, so fix a day and time.

Can I keep 100 % if the guest cancels?

Only if it is proportionate to what you lose: the law treats disproportionately high compensation as unfair (article 85.6). And if you keep the payment when they cancel, you must provide an equivalent amount if you cancel (article 87.2).

Is it better to charge or hold the amount on the card?

For services a few days away, hold it: cancelling a hold is free and on Stripe it lasts 7 days for online payments, while refunding a payment doesn't return the fee. A hold requires the customer to agree to the exact amount (article 47 of Royal Decree-law 19/2018).

What do the Balearics require on deposits and cancellations?

Decree 20/2015 requires prices before acceptance, invoices showing advance payments and guarantees, and cancellation compensation on the terms agreed at booking. Breaching the bookings and cancellations rules is a minor offence under Act 8/2012.

Sources

This article is for information only and is not tax or legal advice.